as LINA MCLAIDLAW
 |
| Won: Academy Award - Best Actress | New York Film Critics Circle - Best Actress |
Joan Fontaine was bestowed the eternal title of "Academy Award winner" only a year after having made a big splash with an acclaimed performance...and just like good 'ol Jimmy Stewart, she ultimately won for a performance that has been deemed by many as being lesser than its predecessor. Obviously her winning is not her fault, and the fact that
Suspicion is a terribly messy and narratively confounding picture isn't her fault either. Her victory can be easily be written off as a "makeup" prize, but the fact that she was named Best Actress by the New York Film Critics Circle (
Inside Oscar says that RKO hadn't even planned on giving
Suspicion a qualifying run until Fontaine had unexpectedly nabbed up the prize) as well suggests to me that voters in 1941 must have seen
something here that they liked. I'll admit, after having read many negative critiques on
Suspicion and Fontaine's win, I came in with the worst expectations. But surprise, surprise--I didn't think
Suspicion or Fontaine was
that bad (big fat sloppy mess? Yeah. AWFUL? nah).